Parallel Criminal Proceedings Under POSH Act: Managing IC Inquiries and Police Investigations
Introduction In cases involving severe allegations—such as physical assault, stalking, or sexual coercion—complaints are frequently registered simultaneously under the POSH Act before the Internal Committee (IC) and under criminal law, such as the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), through a Police First Information Report (FIR). This dual track creates operational confusion for employers, with respondents often arguing that the IC inquiry should be stayed or paused until the police investigation or criminal trial concludes. 1. Independence of IC Inquiries and Criminal Proceedings Indian courts have repeatedly clarified that an IC inquiry and criminal proceedings operate in entirely independent legal domains. A criminal trial evaluates offences against the State under the higher evidentiary threshold of "beyond a reasonable doubt," whereas a POSH inquiry evaluates workplace misconduct under service rules using the civil standard of "preponderance of probability....